Exploring India’s Multi National Companies, Godmen and the Politicians
India’s intricate relationship between corporations and the political sphere has witnessed a significant transformation, particularly in the realm of electoral funding. Over recent election cycles, corporate funding has seen a substantial uptick, escalating from approximately Rs. 621.4 million in FY 2004-05 to a striking Rs. 5.7 billion by FY 2014-15, underscoring the deepening entanglements of business interest within the democratic framework [1]. The introduction of the electoral bond scheme in 2017 further cloaked these financial transactions in opacity, allowing corporations to wield unprecedented influence without the necessity of disclosure, with a staggering 67.98% of these bonds being redeemed by the BJP in certain financial years, spotlighting the potent nexus between money, politics, and corporate India [1].
In the backdrop of growing concern among business leaders, this nexus is painted as one of the gravest threats to the Indian economy [2]. The seamless meshing of religion, business, and politics not only raises questions about the integrity of democratic institutions but also about the sanctity of secular principles [3]. As corporations, multi-national companies, and influential godmen navigate through this political drama, the need for a vigilant judiciary, active media, and informed public discourse to dismantle this nexus becomes paramount. This exploration goes beyond the surface, delving into the role of India’s corporations in maintaining and benefiting from these intertwining relationships and how they impact the democratic ethos of the country [2][3].
The Rise of Godmen in Indian Society
The rise of godmen in Indian society is a multifaceted phenomenon, shaped by cultural, socioeconomic, and political factors. Below are key elements contributing to their prominence:
Cultural and Socioeconomic Influences:
Urbanization and Spiritual Vacuum: Increasing urbanization and modernization have led to a spiritual void in people’s lives, with godmen offering a sense of belonging, identity, and security to their followers [11].
Media and Rising Incomes: The liberalization of the media, coupled with rising incomes, has facilitated the growing wealth and prominence of godmen. This is further amplified by the political popularity of the Hindu nationalist movement [9].
Learned Helplessness: Economic struggles and a lack of resources lead to frustration and learned helplessness among individuals, making them more susceptible to the promises of miracles and salvation offered by godmen [12].
Political and Legal Framework:
Political Patronage: Godmen often wield significant influence over their followers, which political parties leverage during elections, thus reinforcing their rise and influence in society [11].
Lack of Accountability: Many spiritual organizations lack accountability and transparency, enabling unscrupulous individuals to exploit their followers. This situation is exacerbated by an education system that often fails to provide a comprehensive understanding of religion and spirituality [11].
Influence and Wealth:
Global Followership: Many godmen have extended their influence beyond India, contributing to their fame and wealth. This global followership underscores the universal appeal of their teachings and practices [13].
Financial Entanglements: The significant wealth amassed by figures like Sathya Sai Baba and Baba Ramdev, through donations and business ventures in ayurvedic medicine and herbal products, raises questions about the transparency of their financial dealings and the use of donations [9][16].
These elements collectively contribute to the complex landscape of godmen in Indian society, highlighting the intricate interplay between cultural beliefs, political dynamics, and socioeconomic factors.
Political Patronage and Power Dynamics
In the intricate web of India’s political and spiritual landscape, the nexus between godmen and politicians emerges as a formidable force, shaping the socio-political milieu. This relationship, characterized by mutual benefits and power dynamics, underscores the complexity of India’s democracy.
Politicians offer protection to corrupt godmen, enabling financial malpractices like money laundering [17]. Godmen provide politicians with captive vote banks and facilitate illegal campaign financing through religious trusts [17]. The judgment against Rampal and the mention of several scandal-involved godmen like Swami Nityanand and Baba Asa Ram emphasize the need to curb political influence on religious figures [18].
The rise of Hindutva politics and the increasing expense of elections further cement the ties between godmen and politicians, enhancing the value of religious endorsements in political campaigns [17]. This symbiotic relationship benefits politicians through laundered money and guaranteed votes, while godmen gain protection and the ability to build financial empires [20].
Corporate Connections and Financial Entanglements
In the intricate web of India’s socio-spiritual landscape, the financial entanglements between corporations and godmen reveal a complex picture of mutual benefit and questionable practices. Here are key insights into these connections:
Wealth Accumulation and Global Presence:
Swami Premananda and Asaram Bapu exemplify the global scale of operations, with Premananda having branches in several countries and Asaram Bapu boasting 400 ashrams worldwide at the time of his conviction [5].
Sathya Sai Baba and Baba Ramdev highlight the immense wealth some godmen control, with Sai Baba leaving behind assets worth approximately $7.8 million and Ramdev having a net worth of $250 million, encompassing yoga universities and a pharmaceutical company among others [9].
Government Scrutiny and Societal Impact:
The Indian government has initiated investigations into the financial holdings of spiritual leaders like Baba Ramdev following protests against government corruption, pointing to a growing concern over the financial practices of these figures [21].
Tax breaks and grants provided to religious institutions like Dera Sacha Sauda by the government help in amassing wealth and power, raising questions about the accountability and business practices of these empires [22].
Legal and Ethical Concerns:
Religious trusts are used by godmen to facilitate money laundering for businessmen and illegal campaign financing for politicians, exploiting loopholes for anonymous donations and mischaracterizing electoral handouts as charitable spending [17].
Allegations of money laundering and sexual abuse, coupled with income-tax investigations by the government, underscore the urgent need for transparency and accountability in the financial dealings of godmen [9][17].
Impact on Society and Public Discourse
The societal impact of the nexus between godmen, corporations, and politicians in India is multifaceted, affecting various aspects of public life and governance:
Distortion of Justice and Public Trust:
Victims of crimes committed by godmen face significant challenges in seeking convictions, often due to the influence these figures wield across societal and political spheres [20].
The Dera Sacha Sauda, with its claim of over 60 million followers, exemplifies how such organizations, under the guise of social welfare, can amass power and challenge the rule of law [22].
Erosion of Democratic Values:
The intertwining of state and religious institutions compromises the secular fabric of the nation, prioritizing divine commands over evidence and logic, thus undermining the principles of democracy [22].
The growing list of blacklisted godmen, despite their controversial actions and allegations, continues to enjoy widespread support, including from high-profile politicians and celebrities, highlighting the pervasive influence of these figures [9][10].
Societal Disillusionment:
Many Indians turn to godmen due to perceived failures in mainstream politics and religion, seeking solace and solutions that they believe are not provided by the existing structures [10].
The tradition of unquestioning loyalty to the guru in Hindu culture facilitates the ease with which godmen can exert their influence, further complicating efforts to challenge their authority or hold them accountable [10].
Breaking the Nexus: Proposals for Reform
To effectively dismantle the intricate nexus between godmen, corporations, and politicians in India, a multi-faceted strategy encompassing legal, political, and societal reforms is imperative. The following proposals outline the necessary steps towards achieving transparency, accountability, and the separation of religion from politics:
Legal and Regulatory Measures:
Implement stricter regulations and oversight of religious organizations and their leaders to ensure transparency and accountability [25].
Strengthen laws against fraud and exploitation, especially in cases involving religious leaders or organizations [25].
The Indian government should regulate the flow of money between politics and religion to prevent corruption and maintain constitutional order [22].
Political and Ethical Reforms:
Encourage political parties to disclose any ties or connections to religious leaders or organizations, with enforced consequences for non-compliance [25].
Legal reforms should focus on introducing stricter penalties for illegal activities and ensuring the swift and fair prosecution of those involved in the nexus [1].
Public Awareness and Media Engagement:
Increase public awareness and education about the dangers of the godmen-politician nexus and the importance of separating religion and politics [25].
Encourage the media to report on and scrutinize the actions of religious leaders and politicians, holding them accountable for any unethical or illegal behavior [25].
Collaboration between civil society organizations, media, and other stakeholders is crucial for building a broad-based reform movement [1].
Addressing this issue requires a concerted effort from all sectors of society, including legal reforms, political will, and heightened public awareness [1].
Conclusion
The exploration of the complex nexus between godmen, politicians, and corporations within India's landscape unveils a multifaceted challenge to its democratic ethos and secular ideals. This article has detailed the historical progression, the financial entanglements, and the societal impact of these relationships, alongside proposing concrete steps toward reform. Highlighting the significant rise in corporate funding of elections and the substantial influence wielded by godmen, it calls for vigilance in maintaining the integrity of democratic institutions and upholding secular principles. Our understanding of how these entities navigate and exploit the sociopolitical realm, emphasises the urgent need for transparency, accountability, and proactive public discourse.
As citizens vested in the future of India's democracy, it becomes imperative to not only be informed but also engage in advocating for systemic reforms that ensure the separation of religion and politics. This includes pushing for legal and regulatory measures that promote accountability and prevent exploitation. While we deliberate on these challenges, we must also explore avenues to foster a more ethical and transparent environment in these spheres of influence, realizing that the strength of a democracy lies in the engagement and action of its citizens. Suggest ways individuals can advocate for transparency and accountability in these spheres of influence, reinforcing our collective responsibility towards nurturing a more equitable society. Through our concerted efforts, we can aspire to dismantle the detrimental nexus and pave the way for a polity that truly reflects the democratic and secular values it stands for.
References
[1] – https://www.thepolisproject.com/read/the-corporate-government-nexus-in-indian-politics-an-analysis-of-corporate-backed-electoral-trusts/
[2] – https://m.economictimes.com/news/company/corporate-trends/politician-corporates-nexus-greatest-threat-for-indian-economy/articleshow/10447063.cms
[3] – https://arunsimonjy.medium.com/business-politics-religion-nexus-4136fc1c1fdd
[4] – https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/captains-musings/the-naked-truth-about-black-money-confessions-of-an-entrepreneur/
[5] – https://thelawbrigade.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Keerthi-Adithi-JLSR.pdf
[6] – https://indianexpress.com/article/india/aashram-attack-controversial-babas-godmen-ram-rahim-asaram-nithyananda-rampal-7591192/
[7] – https://www.newindianexpress.com/galleries/nation/2017/Aug/26/the-ram-rahim-model-10-controversial-gurus-in-india-100754.html
[8] – https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/chandraswami-the-rise-and-fall-of-a-high-flyer/articleshow/58811428.cms
[9] – https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/indias-godmen-face-questions-about-wealth/2011/07/06/gIQA30iMAI_story.html
[10] – https://www.vice.com/en/article/k7a859/india-obsessed-with-godmen-and-cults
[11] – https://www.reuters.com/article/india-godman-society-idINKCN1B81RM/
[12] – https://www.quora.com/Why-does-India-produce-godmen-so-consistently-and-why-do-people-in-India-have-that-undying-urge-to-have-a-Messiah
[13] – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godman_(India)
[14] – https://www.hindustantimes.com/columns/cult-of-godmen-rising-faith-in-the-unreasonable/story-sxh3ng7cNn0cBEbwK7FDfN.html
[15] – https://www.outlookindia.com/national/politicised-godmen-why-do-the-babas-get-traction-in-india–news-287411
[16] – https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-main-business-of-Indian-god-men-spiritual-gurus-and-mystical-babas
[17] – https://globalanticorruptionblog.com/2020/07/24/unholy-alliance-how-and-why-indias-politicians-protect-indias-corrupt-godmen/
[18] – https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/haryana/news-detail-669207
[19] – https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/politics-of-divine-intervention/article23596145.ece
[20] – https://www.oneindia.com/india/india-country-godmen-politics-not-divinity-their-source-of-power-2530688.html
[21] – https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/07/12/137793095/scrutiny-grows-for-indias-spiritual-leaders-and-their-wealth
[22] – https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/godmens-own-country/article23596081.ece
[23] – https://www.indiatimes.com/news/india/7-indian-godmen-who-thought-they-were-indomitable-until-the-law-caught-up-with-them-328535.html
[24] – https://www.livemint.com/Companies/I4PJu6ic9Aqd7KpMtqsPJJ/The-billionaires-and-the-guru-How-Singh-brothers-burnt-thro.html
[25] – http://q18.baltimorescholars.jhu.edu/enjfph28mam13
Leave a Reply